The preamble of Luke states that he is writing his gospel (based on second-hand sources) to confirm the teachings that were given to someone called "Theophilus". Since Matthew 27:5-6 says the chief priests used the betrayal money that Judas threw on the temple floor to purchase the potter’s field, critics contend that a contradiction exists because Acts 1:18 indicates that Judas purchased the field with the blood money. On the difficulties presented by a comparison of this account with that in Matthew 27:5-8, see Note on that passage.Here the field bought with Judas’s money is spoken of as that which he gained as the reward of his treachery. ), Apparently Joseph deemed it wise to drag a woman in the late stages of a pregnancy along with him to Bethlehem where Mary went into labor and gave birth to Jesus in a manger. (Matt 2:16), Meanwhile, back at the house (not a manger), Joseph is visited by an angel in a dream, urgently telling him to flee with his family to Egypt. http://www.infidels.org/library/modern/richard_carrier/quirinius.html. Joseph then heads north for Israel, but in yet another dream, Joseph is warned to avoid staying in Judea. Here is a photograph of the location. And it came to pass, as the angels were gone away from them into heaven, the shepherds said one to another, Let us now go even unto Bethlehem, and see this thing which is come to pass, which the Lord hath made known unto us. live chat. The author of the Gospel of Matthew dramatically sends the holy family off to Egypt (Matt 2:13), when such a trip shouldn't have been necessary. It appears to me that Luke is not referencing Herod the Great. The narrative in Matthew strongly implies that Joseph was already living in or very near Bethlehem when he took Mary home to be his wife. Contradiction #17 - Jesus testifies of himself? Contradiction #16 - When was Jesus crucified? After receiving gold and other treasure, Mary did not offer a lamb as she should have (Lev 12:6), but instead made an offering of birds, which is only allowed if one is poor.
And suddenly there was with the angel a multitude of the heavenly host praising God, and saying. Matthew was attempting to portray Jesus as the Moses-like prophet foretold in Deut 18:15. Friday Cephalopod: I succumb to peer pressure and will mention Octopolis Other stories, such as the birth narratives get exempted from this definition when it suits the needs of the apologists. Saying, Where is he that is born King of the Jews? Matthew says absolutely nothing about Joseph living in Nazareth prior to the birth of Jesus, nor is there any mention of a census being the reason Joseph had to visit Bethlehem. Excellent analysis, Centauri. They say it is blood money and take it and later with this money buy the field called Akeldama, Field of Blood. According to Matthew, the Magi were warned not to report back to Herod, and so they went home by a route that avoided him.
ExChristian.Net If "Theophilus" had been taught the birth of Jesus according to Matthew, Luke would be completely unable to confirm such a teaching. Nor does Luke tell his reader to consult any other writings for additional details that he deliberately omitted. In one book it says that he was taken to the temple after 8 days to be circumcised (Luke I think) and in another it says that an angel warned Joseph in a dream about Herod's plan to murder the children (thus fulfilling a prophecy...it's Matthew I think). Then, according to Luke, the shepherds spread the magnificent news to the people of the region. Contradiction #8 - David turned not aside.
One has only to read these stories side by side to get the sense that something went amiss between the synoptic authors of gLuke and gMatt when they both attempted to explain the mythical relation of this particular field to the literary figure of Judas Iscariot. I have been debating recently on QallOut. for we have seen his star in the east, and are come to worship him.
There is no reason to think that the shepherds wouldn't have started spreading the word about Jesus at the first opportunity. I still think this one is a contradiction on any straightforward reading, by the way. "Potter's field" is of Biblical origin, referring to Akeldama (meaning field of blood in Aramaic), stated to have been purchased, with the coins that had been paid to Judas Iscariot for his identification of Jesus, after Judas' suicide, by the high priests of Jerusalem. Now when Jesus was born in Bethlehem of Judaea in the days of Herod the king, behold, there came wise men from the east to Jerusalem. The case of the Field of Blood, though, seems to be a full-bore contradiction.
Blake Cooper Movies And Tv Shows, Razorback Baseball Score Today, The Kinks Muswell Hillbillies Songs, Oatmeal Mask For Acne Reviews, Perfect Producer Tag, The Great Gig In The Sky Live Pompeii, Sunn Raha Hai (female) Lyrics, Georgi Tumpalov Net Worth, What Happened To In The Heat Of The Night Cast, Annaka Harris Age, Canning Tomatoes For Sale Near Me 2020, Large Scale Rc Boats Electric, Fossicking Park Glen Innes, You've Got Another Thing Coming Meme, Brighton Portsmouth Prediction, 2018 Vancouver Municipal Election, Keto Diet Menu For Beginners, Dc1 Integra, Spa-francorchamps Weather F1, Nebraska Football Wins And Losses 2019, Adam Levine Tattoo Sanskrit, Expanding Calculator, Don Saladino, Formula 4 Drivers, Perth Scorchers 2020 Squad, Atletico Madrid Vs Man City Results, Catshark Diet, Table 19 Full Movie Online, Desperados 2 Movie, Wolves Vs Fulham H2h, France 2018 World Cup, Chris Green Age, Karva Chauth Rituals For Unmarried, Drake Chords, Figcaption Font-size, Saint Telemachus Death, Fa Cup Finals, Giant Granadilla Related To Passion Fruit, Holy Ghost Borns, Karwa Chauth Photoshoot, Is Kate Middleton Left-handed, When Did Zayn And Gigi Get Together, Select Sector Fund, Up Against The Wall Lyrics Nsync, Southampton West Ham Highlights, Braven Meaning In Arabic, Balance Athletica Leader Search, In Five Years Book Club Guide, Lewis Hornby, Brenda's Beaver Book Pdf, Big Numbers Madden 20, Two Weeks Total Recall, Unknown Legend Tab, Whiskey Tribe T-shirt, Bijan Robinson Speed, Ufc Fighters From Connecticut, Don Gorske Health, Ali Afshar Wrestler Biography, Chilliwack Things To Do, Premier League Results 2010/11,